BY MARTIN KUHRT

Rome, 68 AD
Archdeacon: Your Grace, have you got a moment?
Bishop: I’ve got a few minutes before my meeting with the new diocesan adviser on clergy wellbeing. A rather impressive young man, recently recruited from the imperial administration. Very good connections, apparently.
Archdeacon: It’s about this fellow Paul of Tarsus. We’ve recently had a couple of complaints about him. A man called Demas and a certain Alexander the Metalworker have raised concerns about bullying and public humiliation. I’ve had a look at the Blue File, and there’s quite a bit of rather worrying material in there about Paul.
Bishop: Really? Give me the gist of it.
Archdeacon: Well, Jewish Pharisaic background. Good education. Had some sort of religious experience on a work trip to Damascus. Claims Jesus appeared to him. After spending some time in Arabia, he was ordained in Antioch. Since then, however, he’s become something of a maverick. Doesn’t seem to recognise ecclesiastical boundaries. Has this idea that ‘the whole world is his parish’, or something of that sort. A bit of a loose cannon, if you ask me.
The first complaint on the file is dated AD 43, early in his ministry. A man called Elymas alleges that Paul verbally abused him in Cyprus. Later that year, the mother of a young man called John Mark complained that Paul had overworked her son, who returned home in tears following the same missionary journey. Then, in AD 47, an associate of Barnabas claims to have witnessed Paul losing his temper at a church council meeting over a job application involving the same young man.
Then there’s a succession of complaints relating to what appear to have been disastrous missionary projects, undertaken without proper risk assessments or adequate consultation. We have reports of his disrespectful treatment of a delegation from Jerusalem at Antioch over some legal compliance matters concerning Gentile converts. Apparently, he was positively rude to Bishop Peter.
There have also been various complaints from Galatia about intemperate written communications, and from Corinth about heavy-handed pastoral interventions in people’s personal relationships. There are even allegations that he failed to turn up for promised pastoral visits.
Then we have further complaints from two people called Alexander and Hymenaeus, both of whom say he cursed them. Extraordinary! He seems to manage to upset people right across the theological spectrum. He’s offended conservatives in some provinces by rather insensitively applauding the ministry of certain women, while here in Rome he’s upset the liberals with some distinctly hardline comments about sexuality.
Someone has also reported an interfaith incident in Philippi. Apparently, Paul showed absolutely no sensitivity towards a young woman’s religious background and spirituality. He lost his temper and actually attempted to ‘exorcise’ her. Her employers have given evidence that the poor girl was never the same afterwards and was subsequently unable to function properly in her job.
More alarmingly, there’s a safeguarding incident involving a young man called Eutychus in Troas. It seems Paul failed to follow the proper procedures.
And, to cap it all, he appears to have spent a considerable amount of time fundraising. Some of those who were encouraged, or perhaps pressured, to contribute financially have quite reasonably begun asking where all the money has gone.
Bishop: Yes, I think I remember now. A former chaplain of mine once mentioned this fellow Paul. He didn’t like him at all. Said he seemed to have an overdeveloped sense of his own spiritual authority and an unusually high doctrine of error and refutation. Apparently, the man sees everything in black and white. Probably some sort of autistic disorder. Repressed homosexual tendencies, perhaps, as well.
We must get this fellow in for a meeting. Don’t tell him what it’s about. If he asks, just say we’d like an informal meeting to discuss some pastoral matters and offer him a little guidance and support in reflecting on his ministry. Make it clear that we’re not contemplating formal disciplinary action at this stage. Otherwise, he might become difficult and turn up with someone from the clergy union.
And whatever you do, don’t mention the Blue File. He might ask to see it before we have our little chat.
Archdeacon: I’m afraid he’s already submitted a Subject Access Request for the file we hold on him, Your Grace.
Bishop: Well, that’s a worrying sign in itself. Who does this fellow think he is, taking that sort of attitude towards us?
Archdeacon: Would you like to read through the file, examine the allegations in detail and decide whether further investigations might be appropriate?
Bishop: Good heavens, no! I haven’t got time to plough through all that material and investigate every last detail. The only relevant fact is that we’ve received several complaints. Whether any of them are substantiated is neither here nor there. It’s quite clear that he’s trouble.
If he refuses to play ball and apologise to the people he’s upset, I’ve always found a little passive-aggressive management works wonders.
Here’s what I suggest. We let him know that, of course, we fully recognise his legal rights and have his best interests at heart. At the same time, we express our pastoral concern and indicate that we would be disappointed if he were to adopt an excessively defensive attitude towards our enquiries.
We should explain that, in our experience, it is most unusual for someone in ordained ministry to attract so many written complaints, and that this is obviously a deeply undesirable state of affairs.
Tell him we’re rather worried about him. Assure him that he’s in our prayers. Perhaps suggest some study leave or counselling, which we could generously fund through our discretionary account.
With a bit of luck, he’ll eventually react, either in writing or in person, in a way that gives us some useful ammunition to deploy against him should the need arise. Perhaps a nice little outburst of anger that we can subsequently cite as evidence of his lack of emotional self-regulation.
Remember, the most important thing is to safeguard ourselves (sorry, I mean, of course, the Church!) against any possible comeback should something scandalous emerge later.
We need to be able to demonstrate that, in the light of what we knew at the time, we took the minimum steps necessary to manage the risk.
Archdeacon: Quite so, Your Grace. You’re most wise. I’m learning so much from you.
Discover more from Safeguarding the Institution
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

