When the Cover-Up Becomes the Greater Crime

BY STEPHEN KUHRT

There is a lesson from history that apparently needs to be learned over and over again: it is often not the original wrongdoing that destroys an individual or institution, but the desperate, dishonest and frequently self-defeating attempts to conceal it.

Watergate should have taught us this

Watergate: When the Cover-Up Became Fatal

In June 1972, five men were arrested after breaking into the Democratic National Committee headquarters at the Watergate complex in Washington. The burglary was connected to President Richard Nixon’s re-election campaign. But what transformed an initially serious political scandal into a constitutional crisis was the subsequent attempt by Nixon and his associates to conceal their involvement, obstruct the investigation and prevent the truth emerging. Nixon eventually resigned as President of the USA in August 1974

The original crime was bad enough. The cover-up proved fatal.

One might have thought that Watergate would have established a permanent principle of public life: if something goes wrong, tell the truth, accept responsibility, deal with the consequences and move on. Instead, organisations and individuals repeatedly make the same mistake. They imagine that protecting their reputation is more important than exposing wrongdoing. They convince themselves that a carefully managed version of events, a little strategic silence and perhaps the sacrifice of a few individuals will make the problem disappear.

It rarely does. Indeed, it usually makes everything considerably worse.

The psychology is understandable, if not excusable. Admitting wrongdoing threatens our self-image, our status and our relationships. For institutions, the stakes can appear even higher. Leaders fear reputational damage, financial consequences, loss of public confidence and the possibility that acknowledging one failure will expose others. So the instinct is to minimise, deflect, deny and control the narrative.

But the irony is that the cover-up creates a second wrongdoing, often more damaging than the first. It introduces dishonesty where there was already misconduct, betrayal where there was already failure, and a loss of trust that can become almost impossible to repair.

Sandpapergate: Unanswered Questions Return

We have a particularly interesting contemporary example in Australian cricket.

The recent press conference given by Pat Cummins over the renewed controversy surrounding Sandpapergate illustrates precisely this problem. The original scandal dates back to 2018, when Cameron Bancroft was caught using sandpaper to alter the condition of the ball during a Test match against South Africa. Steve Smith, David Warner and Bancroft were subsequently punished.

Yet, eight years later, the controversy has returned with renewed force following claims in Usman Khawaja’s autobiography that knowledge of the ball-tampering extended much further into the Australian team than the three players who were sanctioned.

Cummins responded forcefully, rejecting the suggestion that the whole team knew about the scheme and describing the allegations as complete and utter nonsense. His lengthy press conference, however, has hardly brought the matter to a conclusion. Indeed, the subsequent interventions of David Warner, former bowler Chadd Sayers and, most recently, Bancroft himself have intensified the controversy. Bancroft has now alleged that the entire team knew what was happening and that bowlers provided feedback on his attempts to alter the ball.

The difficulty for Cricket Australia is that the original response appears to have left too many unanswered questions. The punishment of three individuals may have provided an immediate solution to a public relations crisis, but it did not necessarily establish the complete truth about what happened or who knew what.

Cricket Australia’s belated decision to establish a forum through which players can give their accounts is welcome. But it also raises an obvious question: why has it taken eight years to create an environment in which the whole story can properly be examined?

The danger is that an institution becomes so invested in defending its previous account that it cannot recognise the need to reconsider it. Every new revelation then becomes another threat to be managed rather than an opportunity to establish the truth.

The Church of England: When Reputation Takes Priority Over People

The Church of England should recognise this psychology all too well.

The safeguarding failures and cover-ups exposed in recent years have demonstrated the devastating consequences of placing institutional reputation above the welfare of vulnerable people. The independent Makin Review, published in November 2024, into the Church’s handling of allegations against John Smyth was particularly damning. It described an extended cover-up, identifying how Church officers had been aware of serious abuse and how information had been deliberately withheld from coming to light.

The review found that a 1982 report detailing Smyth’s abuse had been actively concealed. It also concluded that further abuse could and should have been prevented. The consequences were not simply reputational. They involved real people whose lives were profoundly damaged, whose voices were not heard and whose suffering was compounded by the institution that should have protected them.

The subsequent resignation of the Archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby, following the publication of the report, brought the institutional consequences into even sharper focus.

There have also been further independent reviews, including the 2026 review of the Church’s handling of another survivor’s case, demonstrating that the challenges of accountability and safeguarding are not confined to a single historical scandal.

What Institutions Must Learn About Accountability

What, then, should the Church learn from Watergate and from the unfolding Sandpapergate controversy?

First, that genuinely protecting any organisation and its role is not the same thing as protecting its reputation. Indeed, the two can become directly opposed. The moment leaders decide that the preservation of the organisation matters more than the people it exists to serve, they have lost their moral bearings.

Second, that partial disclosure is not the same as honesty. Apologies that avoid uncomfortable questions, investigations that stop short of examining institutional responsibility, and disciplinary action directed only at the most exposed individuals cannot deliver genuine accountability. Survivors must be listened to and placed at the centre of the process. Independent scrutiny must be welcomed rather than treated as a threat.

Third, leaders must understand that telling the truth is not destructive. It is the beginning of institutional recovery. Trust cannot be demanded, managed or manufactured through public relations. It has to be earned through honesty, transparency and demonstrable change.

Truth, the Gospel and the Way Forward

And here, for the Church in particular, there is a profoundly important theological dimension.

In John’s Gospel, Jesus declares: “Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free” (John 8.32).

These words are sometimes treated as a general encouragement to intellectual honesty. But their significance is much deeper. Jesus is speaking about the liberating power of truth in the context of a relationship with him. Truth is not simply a useful management principle or a means of avoiding reputational damage. It is fundamental to the Christian understanding of freedom, integrity and relationship with God.

A Church that conceals abuse, protects powerful individuals or manipulates the truth to preserve its standing is not merely making a public relations mistake. It is acting in direct contradiction to the Gospel it proclaims.

There is a particular tragedy in the suggestion that abuse was concealed because its exposure might damage the work of God. As the Church itself has acknowledged in responding to the Makin Review, no one should believe that covering up abuse can ever be justified in the name of the Gospel.

The reality is precisely the opposite. Concealment damages the Church’s witness. It makes its proclamation of truth sound hollow and its claims to embody the love of Jesus Christ increasingly difficult to believe.

The way forward is not complicated, although it may be profoundly uncomfortable. Tell the whole truth. Acknowledge responsibility. Stop protecting institutional reputation at the expense of people. Make accountability real. And demonstrate through actions, not simply words, that things have changed.

Watergate should have taught us that the cover-up can be more destructive than the original offence. Sandpapergate is demonstrating how unresolved questions can poison an institution for years. The Church of England must learn that safeguarding failures compounded by institutional concealment represent not just a crisis of governance, but a crisis of Christian integrity.

Ultimately, the truth does set people free. But only if we are prepared to tell it, hear it and act upon it. And that applies just as much to institutions as it does to individuals.

Join the conversation...